Laws of the Final Frontier: What is Space Law?
Many of us are quite familiar with the laws in our area. But have you ever wondered about the laws that extend far beyond your city, state, country or even world? Maybe you’ve asked yourself, “Are there laws in space?”
As humanity has begun to explore what lies beyond Earth, rules of space have been established to ensure the rule of order beyond the earth’s atmosphere.
Today, this set of treaties and agreements is known as space law. As we continue to explore, this field will expand right along with our knowledge of the cosmos.
What is Space Law?
Space law is a broad term that encompasses the entire body of law that governs space-related objects and activities.
According to the United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs (UNOOSA), space law, much like general international law, comprises a variety of international agreements, treaties, conventions, and United Nations General Assembly resolutions as well as rules and regulations of international organizations.
Space law originated in the 1950s when humanity first attempted to leave Earth’s atmosphere and explore the mysteries beyond it. Since then, incredible advances have been made — and laws to govern those advances have followed.
As described by Cleveland State University Professor, Mark Sundhal, space law is multidimensional. On the international level, treaties prescribe norms and rule sets applicable to governments, which are then implemented and enforced through domestic laws and regulations. Domestic laws can be found at both the country/federal level or at the level of further political subdivisions, such as at the level of state law in the United States or provincial level in other countries.
In addition to these treaties and domestic laws, the international community has also recognized a number of non-binding “soft” law instruments such as resolutions, understandings and guidelines. These instruments are effective in establishing voluntary rules and standards that countries develop together (most often under the auspices of the UN).
The Evolution of Space Law
After the Second World War, a new kind of rivalry emerged. The Soviet Union (USSR) and the United States, as well as their respective allies, were vying to become the most powerful and influential nations in the world and beyond. This conflict led to the Cold War, which was characterized less by outright military action and more by political rivalry, economic influence and propaganda due to the nation’s respective increase in nuclear power and the development of Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBM).
One of the primary ways in which these two nations competed with each other during the Cold War became known as the “Space Race”- a competition to be the first to create and develop technologies that would put satellites and astronauts in space.
In 1957, the USSR successfully launched Sputnik 1, the first-ever artificial satellite, marking the beginning of the Space Age. The United States followed suit in 1958 when President Eisenhower signed the National Aeronautics and Space Act into effect, creating NASA. That same year, the United States sent its first satellite, Explorer 1, into orbit.
Since both countries now had technology stably orbiting the planet, they became highly invested in creating international space laws to protect their satellites – and eventually, their astronauts.
Former Astronaut, Neil Armstrong
Image Source: NASA Archives
On December 13, 1958, the United Nations General Assembly adopted its first space-related resolution in an attempt to recognize the common interest in outer space and find a path to peaceful exploration. The following year, the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (COPUOS) was created “to govern the exploration and use of space for the benefit of all humanity: for peace, security and development.”
Milestones quickly accumulated in the 1960s, from Valentina Tereshkova’s successful Earth orbit in 1963 to Neil Armstrong’s first step onto the moon's surface in 1969. In between those milestones, the 1967 Outer Space Treaty was created by the United Nations legal subcommittee and accepted in the General Assembly, which still exists today.
This monumental treaty forever shaped space law, “banning the stationing of weapons of mass destruction in outer space, prohibiting military activities on celestial bodies, and creating legally binding rules that govern the peaceful exploration and use of space.”
While these laws governing military action in space were being developed, simultaneous discussions were happening regarding the governance of communication technologies. The International Telecommunication Union (ITU), the oldest United Nations agency, was created in 1865 to govern telegraph communication. In the years since it has evolved alongside new forms of communication, and it was an early adopter of the importance of space governance in communication.
Today, the ITU’s slogan is “committed to connecting the world,” and their constitution outlines several ways this commitment encompasses outer space satellite communications. In short, their duty is to control and regulate the use of radio communication and orbit paths for satellites that orbit the Earth.
According to the Wilson Center, 72 nations possess space agencies today, and 14 could launch devices capable of maintaining orbit. In addition, private stakeholders have begun their own space initiatives in recent years, proving that “space exploration is no longer a domain reserved for wealthy nations alone.”
Now, more than ever, the world needs space lawyers who deeply understand space law to preserve the Earth and its environment, hold perpetrators accountable for damages, settle disputes, govern the use of space technology and enforce international cooperation for a peaceful world.
International and Domestic Agreements
The United Nations has adopted five treaties and five governing principles concerning outer space. Several important pieces of legislation govern American space law in the United States.
United Nations Treaties on Outer Space
- The Outer Space Treaty (1967) was created to enact international laws concerning space exploration, the claiming of space territory and the testing and use of weapons in space. In 1967, 100 countries signed this treaty. It has since been ratified by 95 additional nations, and its provisions are still in effect.
- The Rescue Agreement (1968) expanded on ideas put forth in the Outer Space Treaty, specifically those pertaining to the rescue and assistance of space personnel. In the agreement, participating nations must “immediately take all possible steps” to rescue and assist astronauts in distress, promptly returning them to the launching nation or assisting in search and rescue missions for space crafts that land in their waters or on their lands.
- The Liability Convention (1972) was crafted by the legal subcommittee of the United Nations for nearly a decade. This document holds participating nations responsible if their space objects cause damage, holding them liable for any damages incurred due to fault on their part.
- The Registration Convention (1975) requires nations to provide details about every space object they launch into orbit to the United Nations. The UN keeps a register that includes the name of the launching nation, the registration number of the object, the launch date and location, the parameters of the orbit and the general purpose of the space object.
- The Moon Agreement (1979) outlines that any activities or objects on the moon's surface should be used exclusively for peaceful purposes. While this document was completed and brought to the UN General Assembly in 1979, it was not ratified by the required minimum of five countries until 1984, which is when it took effect. This agreement bans weapons testing and military bases and maneuvers on the moon.
United Nations Governing Space Law Principles
- The Declaration of Legal Principles (1963) states that no one can claim or assume ownership of celestial bodies or outer space. It outlines that all space activities must be done with good intentions and are subject to international law. Finally, it declares that a nation that conducts space activity must be accountable for what transpires, including the assumption of responsibility for damages.
- The Broadcasting Principles (1982) legislation was created to ensure the free exchange of cultural and scientific information acquired in space, using it to enhance the lives of all people and not just those of the nation who launched the expedition. It also explains that findings must be reported to the United Nations.
- The Remote Sensing Principles (1986) is a compiled list of fifteen principles that relate to sensing the Earth with electromagnetic waves. Countless satellites do this every day, scanning the Earth and gathering important data. These principles outline that sensing technology must be used in accordance with international law. It should also be used for the good of all nations and to protect the Earth and its environment.
- The Nuclear Power Sources Principles (1992) is a document that contains eleven principles regarding the proper use of nuclear power in space. It holds participating nations to international laws concerning the use of nuclear power, outlines rules for nuclear safety, and dictates that all countries “launching space objects with nuclear power sources on board shall endeavor to protect individuals, populations and the biosphere against radiological hazards.”
- The Benefits Declaration (1996) was created to highlight the importance of international cooperation in the use of outer space. The document states that space exploration should benefit all countries, particularly developing nations and their needs.
United States Space Law Legislation
Title 51 of the United States Code contains national and commercial space program legislation. Many pieces of important legislation can be found within this document, including
- The Communications Act of 1934 predates space law and governs satellite use as it pertains to radio.
- The National Aeronautics & Space Act of 1958, signed into law by President Eisenhower, established NASA and set key space objectives.
- The Land Remote-Sensing Commercialization Act (1984) allowed for the privatization of Earth-imaging satellite operations.
- The Weather Research and Forecasting Innovation Act of 2017 allows commercial weather satellites to operate and lets NOAA purchase weather information from them.
- The NASA Transition Authorization Act of 2017 focuses on the human exploration of deep space, scientific investments and growing the commercial space sector. The act emphasizes the importance of NASA’s continuity of purpose from one presidential administration to the next and created the TREAT Astronauts Act, which guarantees medical treatment for astronauts whose health is negatively affected by space missions.
- The National Defense Authorization Act of 2020 establishes the U.S. Space Force and outlines its mission, duties and chain of command.
Parameters of Space Law
Today, space law has many parameters and governing principles. If you choose to pursue a career in space law, you may specialize in one of these areas.
- Space exploration is primarily concerned with the rights and responsibilities of nations involved in space exploration missions and initiatives.
- Liability in space law governs responsibility and liability for damage caused in space or by space objects when they return to Earth.
- Weapon use focuses on laws regarding the use of weapons in space, sometimes with a particular emphasis on weapons of mass destruction.
- Rescue efforts are concerned with the obligations of nations in rescuing astronauts, as outlined in the Rescue Agreement.
- Environmental preservation specializes in laws that protect the space environment and the Earth’s atmosphere.
- Information sharing centers around parties' requirements to share information about their space activities.
- New technologies consider how space law should accommodate new technologies and when legislation should be created around these technologies.
- Ethics focuses on the ethical considerations of space exploration.
Integration with Other Fields of Law
While space law is an important new frontier, it also works in tandem with many other aspects of legal practice.
For example, international law and even maritime law relate directly to space activities, as seen repeatedly in the United Nations principles. Environmental law can inform space law as we work to find best practices for protecting and preserving the Earth and its environment. Property law and intellectual property law will become more intertwined with space law as space resources become more attainable for private parties and nations. Lastly, dispute resolution is necessary when two parties disagree about space activities, information or resources.
If you have a background in any of these fields, or if you’re interested in pursuing one, a career in space law could hold a promising future for you.
The Future of Space Law
Space technology is evolving faster than ever, and scientific innovations will significantly impact space law. As the commercialization of space assets picks up pace, legislation must follow closely behind. Space law will be at the forefront of ensuring that space exploration and activity are fair and peaceful for nations and privatized operations alike.
As new innovations and segments in the space industry begin to emerge, so do the legal questions surrounding them. Questions surrounding topics such as on-orbit refueling and repair of satellites, private space stations, space tourism, property rights, liability, safety, environmental law, the protection of lunar heritage sites, space traffic management, and deconfliction of overlapping lunar missions on the moon's south pole, will all necessitate unique solutions, many of which requiring a combination of international legislation and domestic law.
Organizations like the United Nations must join forces with state agencies like NASA and experienced practitioners of space law to further create new agreements and treaties to create safe and equitable ventures that are focused on the good of all humanity. Space law offers a challenging, exciting and rewarding career opportunity for those who dare to face the final frontier.
Your Space Law Journey Begins at Cleveland State
Space law is both important and relevant to our world today. If you want to pursue a career in space law, consider earning your Juris Doctor (J.D.) from Cleveland State University (CSU).
At CSU, you’ll find one of the few ABA-accredited online J.D. programs in the United States. With competitive tuition rates and the ability to earn your degree online in just 10 semesters, you’ll enjoy a combination of synchronous and asynchronous coursework and a total of six residential weekends that allow you to participate in immersive lawyering skills training and connect with professors and fellow students.
Cleveland State University will help you gain the legal training you need to excel in space law. The Global Space Law Center (GSLC) at CSU is the only center of its kind at any law school in the nation. Founded and directed by internationally-known Professor Mark Sundahl, the GSLC offers many ways to further your education and build connections in the field of space law, including:
- Online Course on Space Law
- Certificate in Space Law
- Online Space Law Research Guide
- Student Space Law Society
- Student-Staffed Research Council
- Student-Authored STARLAW Blog
Learn more about how CSU’s Online JD can help you take the giant leap toward the career of your dreams.